I Always Wanted It This Way has been played 13 times, at 0.7% of Phish performances. It has been performed, on average, once every 9.8 shows since its debut 127 shows ago. It was last performed February 21, 2020 (2 shows ago).

• 2020-02-21, Cancun, Quintana Roo, Mexico
• 2019-12-08, North Charleston, SC
• 2019-07-10, Uncasville, CT
• 2019-06-18, Toronto, Ontario, Canada
• 2019-02-21, Riviera Maya, Quintana Roo, Mexico
• 2018-10-28, Rosemont, IL
• 2018-08-07, Camden, NJ
• 2018-07-18, Stateline, NV
• 2017-12-29, New York, NY
• 2017-07-22, New York, NY
• 2016-10-29, Las Vegas, NV
• 2016-10-24, Grand Prairie, TX
• 2016-10-15, North Charleston, SC