In the Midnight Hour has been played 5 times, at 0.27% of Phish performances. It has been performed, on average, once every 372 shows since its debut 1,860 shows ago. It was last performed September 27, 1985 (1,836 shows ago).

• 1985-09-27, Burlington, VT
• 1985-03-04, Burlington, VT
• 1984-12-01, Burlington, VT
• 1984-11-03, Burlington, VT
• 1983-12-02, Burlington, VT