She Caught the Katy and Left Me a Mule to Ride has been played 6 times, at 0.32% of Phish performances. It has been performed, on average, once every 301.3 shows since its debut 1,808 shows ago. It was last performed December 28, 2010 (348 shows ago).

• 2010-12-28, Worcester, MA
• 1998-08-14, Limestone, ME
• 1998-07-21, Phoenix, AZ
• 1988-07-30, Telluride, CO
• 1987-08-29, South Burlington, VT
• 1987-04-29, Burlington, VT
• 1986-12-06, Shelburne, VT